Warning: By their nature, text files cannot include scanned images and tables. 
The process of converting documents to text only can cause formatting changes 
and misinterpretation of the contents can sometimes result. Wherever possible 
you should refer to the original PDF version of this document 

CAIRNGORMS NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY 

 
OUTCOME OF THE PLANNING COMMITTEE CALL-IN held electronically on Friday, 25th November 2011 

 

PARTICIPATING MEMBERS 

 

Peter Argyle 

Eleanor Mackintosh 

Angela Douglas 

Mary McCafferty 

Jaci Douglas 

Willie McKenna 

David Green 

Gordon Riddler 

Kate Howie 

Gregor Rimell 

Marcus Humphrey 

Brian Wood 

Gregor Hutcheon 

Allan Wright 

APOLOGIES: 

 Katrina Farquhar 

Ian Mackintosh 

Martin Price 

 NO RESPONSE RECEIVED: 

 Duncan Bryden 

Dave Fallows 

 

1. The CNPA has taken a decision to trail the use of electronic systems to carry out its 
Call-in meetings. 

2. Members were able to view the Call-in presentation on the CNPA website 
(www.cairngorms.co.uk) between 12.00 noon on Wednesday, 23 November and 


12.00 noon on Friday, 25 November 2011. 


3. Apologies were received from the above Members. 


DECLARATION OF INTEREST BY MEMBERS ON ANY ITEMS APPEARING 
ON THE CALL-IN PRESENTATION 

 

4. Gordon Riddler declared a direct interest in Planning Application No. 2011/0371/DET 
as Director of BRD. 


PLANNING APPLICATION CALL-IN DECISIONS 

(Electronic Presentation, prepared by Andrew Tait, Planning Officer) 

 

5. 2011/0368/LBC - No Call-in 
6. 2011/0369/DET - No Call-in 
7. 2011/0370/DET - No Call-in 
8. 2011/0371/DET - No Call-in 
9. 2011/0372/DET - No Call-in 
10. 2011/0373/PPP - No Call-in 
11. 2011/0374/DET - No Call-in 
12. 2011/0375/DET - No Call-in 
13. 2011/0376/LBC - No Call-in 
14. 2011/0377/DET - No Call-in 


 

15. 2011/0378/LBC - Restoration of Former Croft House with Ancillary Storage 


At Derelict Croft House at Tomintoul, Braemar 

 

The decision was to call-in the application for the following reason: 

This listed building application involves the renovation of a cottage 
that is recognised as being of national significance to the cultural 
heritage of the area and has recently been ÔAÕ listed by Historic 
Scotland. The proposal is of general significance to the aims of the 
National Park, including the first aim of conserving and enhancing 
the natural and cultural heritage of the area, and is also of 
relevance in the context of the social and economic development 
of the area 
16. 2011/0379/DET - Re-positioning of New Dwellinghouse and Alterations to External 
Finishes At Tomintoul Croft, Braemar 

 The decision was to call-in the application for the following reason: 

 
The proposed development is for a new dwelling on an elevated 
site, adjacent to a cottage which although in a derelict condition is 
recognised as being of national significance to the cultural heritage 
of the area and has recently been ÔAÕ listed by Historic Scotland. 
The proposal is of general significance to the aims of the National 
Park, including the first aim of conserving and enhancing the 
natural and cultural heritage of the area, and is also of relevance in 
the context of the social and economic development of the area 

COMMENTING ON APPLICATIONS NOT CALLED-IN BY THE COMMITTEE 

 

17. The planning officers noted Members comments and were delegated with the 
responsibility of whether or not to submit the comments to the Local Authorities. The 
following comments were passed on to the Local Authorities. 


 
18. 2011/0368/LBC - Construction of 8 No. Buttresses 

At Bridge to the North West of Inverey House, Inverey, Braemar 

 
In terms of cultural heritage the CNPA would comment that any 
new stone should be carefully selected to match the existing 
bridge and that AberdeenshireÕs Natural and Built Heritage Team 
are consulted upon the application. 
 

19. 2011/0370/DET - Extension to Dwellinghouse and Formation of Ancillary 
Accommodation 


At Auchallater, Braemar 

The ancillary accommodation proposed should remain as such and 
be conditioned if the application is approved.